dYdX Chain: End of Season 9 Re-Launch Incentive Analysis

Overview

Chaos Labs is pleased to provide a comprehensive review of the ninth trading season on the dYdX Chain. This analysis encompasses all facets of exchange performance, emphasizing the impact of the Launch Incentive Program.

We are diligently fine-tuning the incentives, ensuring they effectively meet their intended goals. By monitoring a broad spectrum of indicators, we aim to understand the rewards program’s dynamics and outcomes.

Key Stats:

  • dYdX Chain has seen over 8.6bn in trading volume across 188 live markets.
  • Over 6300 traders were active through season 9.
  • Over $190m of open interest, down 45% from the beginning of the season.
  • The dYdX Chain has approximately $280m USDC in TVL deposited on the exchange at the end of season 9, down 24% from the beginning of the season.
  • Liquidity within 100 bps has increased by around 25% across the top markets

dYdX Chain Trading

The dYdX Chain has seen over $8.6bn in trading volume across 188 live markets. This is a decrease of 4% compared to the preceding 30-day period.

Open interest has decreased over the season from $345m to $190m, a decrease of 45%.

Open interest has historically fluctuated significantly with market conditions. It declined notably during the market crash at the beginning of February and stayed on the same level.

Traders have paid almost $48.6m in fees to stakers securing the dYdX Chain since inception. $1.8m of this came in season 9 of the launch incentive program.

dYdX Chain Liquidity

A focus of the program in its current iteration is growing liquidity across all markets to improve the trading experience for users.

Liquidity in the majors, as measured by median liquidity within 100bps, has continued improving—particularly among the more developed markets—such that large markets now maintain over $4,000,000 in liquidity within 100bps most of the time. Interestingly, however, three markets sitting at the lower end of the top 10 by volume this season exhibited significantly less liquidity—approximately eight times lower than the closest comparable market.

See the table below for liquidity trends in some major markets sorted by traded volume.

Market Current Preceding 30 day Change
BTC-USD $33,268,404 $24,350,344 27%
ETH-USD $28,981,751 $21,774,520 25%
SOL-USD $12,258,204 $9,290,960 24%
DOGE-USD $5,217,024 $3,605,075 31%
XRP-USD $4,996,573 $3,360,615 33%
ADA-USD $4,315,219 $3,257,880 25%
LINK-USD $4,171,518 $2,913,961 30%
SUI-USD $558,367 $578,790 -4%
LTC-USD $408,317 $330,044 19%
FLOKI-USD $298,050 $206,851 31%

The impact remains broad across markets, with the long tail increasing dramatically over the season. Overall liquidity within 1% is up 32% on the season.

Orderbook Liquidity Above $1000k Above $500k Above $250k Above $100k Above $50k Above $10k Total Liquidity ($m)
30 days ago 14 16 49 67 99 137 108m
Now 14 16 53 71 112 145 143m

Funding

During Season 9, average funding rates in most major markets declined, aligning with broader market trends.

Market Average Median Max Min
ETH 5.68% 2.96% 53.87% -112.24%
BTC 10.37% 9.09% 77.85% -39.09%
SOL 5.09% 2.85% 98.44% -150.23%
DOGE -2.34% 1.09% 158.23% -267.18%
XRP -0.47% 0.00% 131.95% -173.12%
SUI 2.96% 0.00% 124.28% -346.57%
LTC 3.82% 0.00% 70.19% -4.71%
ADA 0.05% 0.00% 22.89% -20.48%
FLOKI -1.00% 0.00% 0.11% -26.17%
LINK 0.32% 0.00% 21.13% -17.30%

Liquidations

This season experienced fewer liquidations compared to the prior period, with a total of $32 million liquidated across all markets during Season 9.

The insurance fund now sits at over $12.8m, bootstrapped predominantly by protocol liquidation fees. Over $0.4m of this came over season 9.

TVL and Deposit Metrics

At the end of Season 9 approximately $280m USDC was deposited in the app on the dYdX Chain, down 24% from $367m USDC at the start of the season.

Program Efficiency Metrics

Much of the above analysis focuses on aggregate metrics, which can be influenced by a small number of traders. Our analysis of the program also encompasses a bottom-up assessment of the impact it has in growing the number of active traders.

This section provides a deep dive into trader-level metrics to highlight the program’s impact across a range of dimensions. This, in turn, forms the basis for the long-term projections around the program’s impact and efficiency.

Daily and Weekly Active Traders

The number of weekly active traders in Season 9 has experienced notable fluctuations, including an initial dip over the end-of-year break, followed by periods of both growth and decline influenced by heightened market volatility which, in turn, led to notable trader churn.

Growing the number of average daily and weekly active traders on dYdX is a guiding principle of the Launch Incentive Program, and significant care is taken to ensure that the incentives appeal to a diverse segment of traders.

Week Average Daily Active Weekly Active Average Weekly Volatility
2024-09-30 1339 2172 35.03%
2024-10-07 1306 2242 32.18%
2024-10-14 1449 2481 33.61%
2024-10-21 1543 2716 28.74%
2024-10-28 1644 2899 32.75%
2024-11-04 1958 3475 42.58%
2024-11-11 2277 4225 57.39%
2024-11-18 2365 4176 40.48%
2024-11-25 2287 4435 35.36%
2024-12-02 2555 4527 42.76%
2024-12-09 2310 4657 39.27%
2024-12-16 2328 4320 50.31%
2024-12-23 1431 3817 36.32%
2024-12-30 1648 3306 30.78%
2025-01-06 2014 3789 37.27%
2025-01-13 2265 3949 49.38%
2025-01-20 2028 4035 55.07%
2025-01-27 2227 3866 42.38%
2025-02-03 1959 4533 46.12%
2025-02-10 1757 2948 31.71%
2025-02-17 1793 2949 27.22%

  • Weekly active traders are defined as traders who make at least one trade during a week.

  • Volatility is measured as the variance of minute-by-minute log returns of BTC. This short time frame accurately measures the volatility experienced by dYdX Chain traders in its largest market better than the traditional daily volatility.

Trader Engagement

Trader engagement is defined as how frequently the active user interacts with the dYdX Chain. This is analyzed across a few dimensions. The ratio of average daily active users to weekly active users broadly signals what portion of weekly active traders make a trade on a given day in the week. When this ratio is high, more traders find value in the product and return for this utility.

From a Launch Incentive Program perspective, the incentives should appeal to traders who are likely to become more regular traders and, therefore, likely to be stickier over the long term.

Another measure analyzed is the number of days traders have been active during season 9. We observe an increase in the cohort of traders who are active on almost a daily basis.

Weekly Trader Breakdown and Retention

Season 9 saw in initial reduction of traders over the end of year break, with mostly existing traders leaving. Most have now returned, however the total is still less than the end of seasons 8 and 7.

The weekly trader retention rate initially dipped due to the end of year holidays over season 9. This has rebounded mostly.

The marginal weekly trader retention rate shows how likely it is for a trader who has traded for a certain number of weeks to trade for one more. This is a slightly different methodology from the retention rate above, as returning traders are treated the same as retained traders here, hence the higher retention numbers.

What is apparent is how much better traders retain the more weeks they have been active. The goal is to get a trader active for at least six weeks, as the data suggests traders are incredibly sticky.

Marginal Weekly Trader Retention Rate

Week Retention Rate
1 57.32%
2 76.47%
3 84.44%
4 88.23%
5 89.41%
6 88.25%
7 92.36%
8 97.02%
9 95.97%
10 96.46%

Summary

There are many aspects contributing to the growth in the dYdX Chain since the Launch Incentive Program began. Attributing growth to specific factors is not an exact science, and we acknowledge the impact market conditions have on trading activity. Given that, here are some highlights from our analysis:

  • Traders spent $1.8m in fees during season 9, and the program will pay out $1.5m in rewards.
  • Liquidity within 100 bps has increased by around 25% across the top markets
  • Over 6300 traders used dYdX Chain during season 9.

Disclaimer

This report is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation for any security, nor does it constitute an offer to provide investment advisory or other services by Chaos Labs. No reference to any specific security constitutes a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold that security or any additional security. Nothing in this report shall be considered a solicitation or offer to buy or sell any security, future, option, or other financial instrument or offer or provide investment advice or service to any person in any jurisdiction. Nothing contained in this report constitutes investment advice or offers any opinion with respect to the suitability of any security, and the views expressed in this report should not be taken as advice to buy, sell, or hold any security. The information in this report should not be relied upon for investing. In preparing the information in this report, we have not considered any particular investor’s investment needs, objectives, and financial circumstances. This information has no regard for the specific investment objectives, financial situation, and particular needs of any specific recipient of this information, and the investments discussed may not be suitable for all investors. Any views expressed in this report were prepared based on the data available when such views were written. Changed or additional information could cause such views to change. All information is subject to possible correction. Information may quickly become unreliable, including market or economic changes.

Throughout the program, Chaos Labs’ role is confined to providing recommendations regarding the allocation of rewards. The actual implementation and distribution of said rewards are subject to the formal approval process of the dYdX Chain governance votes. Any actions pertaining to reward distribution shall only be executed following affirmative governance votes within the dYdX Chain framework.

As a staker on the DYDX chain, I appreciate you submitting this report.
This corroborates the perception that the various incentive campaigns do not have a clear correlation with the evolution and retention of the number of users.
Additionally, as indicated in the 2024 report, the DYDX chain generated 45M in fees and paid 63M in rewards, which represents a clear imbalance between fees and rewards and demonstrates the unsustainability of this program.
I think it is fair to conclude that, despite the acceptance and voting of its implementation by the community, there is no evidence that the investment made in the various incentive campaigns has created value for the protocol, but rather contributed to the erosion of DYDX tokens from the treasury and dumping of DYDX tokens on the open market.
Some alternatives:

  1. Redirect the requested funding to the staking program and reinvest the liquidity generated in USDC in Megavault in order to increase its profitability for depositors;
  2. Redirect the requested funding to the staking program and use the liquidity generated in UDSC to fund a rewards campaign (in USDC) reinvented from scratch, whose USDC generated by the staking program is divided by all the points generated by the campaign, completely eliminating its funding through the distribution of the DYDX token.

Suggestions for a possible new rewards campaign mechanism:

  1. New mechanics that reward long-term users, whether they are traders or depositors in the Megavault;
  2. It must include all users regardless of their contribution volume in terms of USD, valuing, above all, the duration of their interaction with the protocol.

It is absolutely necessary for the community to develop a critical and pragmatic stance on this program and its continuity.

It is also necessary to understand that the best way to capture and retain new users is the constant development of the product offered to its users.

I invite the community to participate in this discussion.